You get a job offer in another city. Your lease still has eight months left. Now you wonder if you can sublet without losing your deposit or your apartment.

That is where real property law section 226-b comes in. It gives New York tenants a legal path to sublet, but the path has rules.

Some rules are about timing, some are about paperwork, and others depend on the building you live in.

Tenants worry about the landlord’s answer, yet the way you ask often matters more. A clean request protects you. A sloppy one can undo you before anyone says a word.

Disclaimer: This article is general information about New York Real Property Law § 226-b, not legal advice. Sublet rights depend on your building type, lease terms, and whether your unit is rent-stabilized. For your situation, consult a licensed New York tenant attorney.

What Does Real Property Law Section 226-b Actually Say?

Section 226-b of New York’s Real Property Law covers a tenant’s right to sublease or assign a residential lease. Both rights depend on your landlord’s consent.

It sits in Article 7, which deals with landlords and tenants. It treats subleasing and assigning as two separate rights.

The sublease right applies only if your building has four or more residential units. You need the landlord’s written consent before you sublet.

The landlord cannot unreasonably withhold that consent. The statute covers leases signed before or after it took effect. Any lease clause that waives these rights is void.

How Does the Sublease Request Process Work?

Tenant and landlord seated at a table reviewing a sublease request form, with a pen, house key and folder on the table

You start the process by mailing a written notice by certified mail. The landlord’s 10-day and 30-day deadlines run from that mailing. Get the request right the first time.

What the Written Request Must Include

Send the request by certified mail, return receipt requested. The statute asks for specific details, and missing one can sink the request. Here is what the request must contain:

  • The length of the sublease term
  • The subtenant’s name, business address, and permanent home address
  • Your reason for subletting
  • Your address while you are away
  • Written consent from any co-tenant or guarantor
  • A copy of the sublease, acknowledged by you and the subtenant
  • A copy of your lease, if you have one

Regular mail does not satisfy the statute. RPL § 226-b(2)(b) calls for certified mail, return receipt requested, and the landlord’s written consent has to come in advance of the subletting.

How the 10-Day and 30-Day Clocks Work

If you’re subletting your place, the landlord doesn’t get unlimited time to sit on your request. The law sets clear deadlines for both sides. Here’s how the timeline actually works, including what happens if the landlord asks for more information before deciding.

The 10-day window

  • The landlord has 10 days from the mailing date to request more info
  • The request must help the landlord judge whether refusing you would be unreasonable (for example, proof of your subtenant’s income)

The 30-day decision clock

  • Starts on the date you mail your original request
  • If the landlord asks for more info, the clock resets. The new deadline runs from whichever is later: the date you mail your answer, or the original start date

If the landlord had stayed silent after March 1, the deadline would have stayed at March 31.

Refusal rules

  • A refusal notice has to state the landlord’s reasons
  • No notice within the window means the sublet is automatically approved. Silence counts as consent

How Is Assigning a Lease Different From Subletting?

Split image with a VS badge: tenant handing a lease and key to a new tenant, and two people reviewing a sublease at a table

A sublease is temporary and keeps you liable. An assignment is permanent, and a different consent standard governs it.

People mix these up constantly. They are not interchangeable.

A sublease hands over occupancy for a set period. You remain the tenant, and the landlord can still look to you.

An assignment hands over the whole lease.

You step out and the new tenant steps in. The consent rules differ too. For an assignment, the owner may refuse without giving any cause.

Reasonableness only comes into play afterward.

If the owner refuses unreasonably, your sole remedy is release from the lease on 30 days’ notice.

If the refusal is reasonable, nothing happens. There is no assignment and no release. A sublease request starts with a reasonableness test, while an assignment request does not.

RPL § 226-b(1) lets the owner withhold consent to an assignment without cause. A lease clause that bans assignments outright is void.

In Bean v Morgan Gun Hill, LLC, a landlord refused to consent to an assignment; the lease clause barring assignments was held void, and the tenant was released from the lease.

What Happens if the Landlord Refuses a Sublet Request?

Landlord’s hand sliding an unsigned sublease request form across a table toward a tenant, with a capped pen beside it

A landlord may refuse only for a reasonable cause. An unreasonable refusal does not automatically make the sublet safe.

Unless you ask a court first, reasonableness gets decided only after the sublet has started, and that timing is where tenants get hurt.

What Counts as a Reasonable Refusal

Courts ask whether the landlord relied on objective factors, such as the subtenant’s financial responsibility and the nature of the occupancy. Landlords commonly point to these grounds:

  • A request that was defective or incomplete
  • A proposed subtenant who could not show steady income
  • Sublease terms that charged more than the legal rent
  • Doubts about whether the tenant planned to return

A guess is not enough on that last point. In 140 E. 46th St. LLC v Murray, the court held that refusing on speculation that the tenant would not come back was unreasonable, because the landlord had no objective basis.

The same court found the refusal unreasonable because the landlord never used the 10-day window to ask for more information.

Landlords do not always lose. In Ben-Reuven v Lincoln Plaza Assoc., the court refused to rule for the tenant as a matter of law because the landlord’s stated concerns, including the sublease’s financial terms and the tenant’s intentions, raised fact questions. A court can weigh the same facts differently in another building.

Sublet Anyway or Go to Court First?

Unless you sue first, reasonableness gets decided after the fact. If you sublet over a refusal, you are betting a judge will later agree with you.

You have two paths. Each carries its own risk.

The first path is to sublet and defend a holdover proceeding. If you lose, you can face eviction and the landlord’s attorney’s fees.

The second path is to ask a court first. You file a declaratory judgment action in Supreme Court before anyone moves in.

That path is slower and costs money up front. It also tells you where you stand before you take the risk.

On fees, the statute itself awards them only when a court finds the landlord acted in bad faith, and courts apply that rule regardless of what the lease says.

A separate rule, RPL § 234, can also shift fees. If your lease lets the landlord recover attorney’s fees, that rule gives you the same right when you successfully defend the case. Read your own lease on this point.

An older Fordham Urban Law Journal note argued that the statute’s only remedies are ending the lease or staying in occupancy, not subletting without consent. The statute’s text points the other way.

If the landlord unreasonably withholds consent, the tenant may sublet in accordance with the request. Courts have treated an unreasonable refusal as a full defense to an illegal-sublet holdover.

When Does Section 226-b Not Apply or Change?

Attorney seated at a wooden desk reading an open law book, with a legal pad and pen beside it and law books on shelves behind

Section 226-b does not cover every home in New York. Rent-stabilized units follow the statute plus extra rules.

Check which group your apartment falls into before you send anything.

Excluded Housing

The sublease right does not reach every building. Public housing falls outside it.

So do units with constitutional or statutory admission criteria. Co-op proprietary leases are excluded as well.

Buildings with fewer than four units fall outside the sublease right too. A small walk-up with three apartments is not covered.

Rent-Stabilized Apartments

If your unit is rent-stabilized, the Rent Stabilization Law, the Emergency Tenant Protection Act, and Rent Stabilization Code § 2525.6 apply on top of § 226-b. They add limits the basic statute lacks.

The first limit is the primary residence requirement. This is your real home, and the sublet cannot change that.

In New York City, Rent Stabilization Law § 26-511(c)(12)(f) bars subletting for more than two years total out of the four years before the sublease ends, counting the sublease you are proposing. Past that, you risk losing your claim to the apartment.

Rent is capped too. The subtenant cannot pay more than the legally regulated rent. A fully furnished unit can carry a 10% surcharge. Nothing beyond that is allowed.

Overcharging a subtenant can mean treble damages and eviction risk. Rent-controlled units are a separate category with their own rules.

What Should You Do Before You Send a Sublet Request?

A few steps taken early can save you from a refusal or a court fight. This list covers what to do before you mail anything.

  • Read your lease for extra rules that sit on top of the statute.
  • Line up your subtenant and collect their details and proof of steady income.
  • Check that your building has four or more residential units.
  • Confirm whether your apartment is rent-stabilized, since extra limits may apply.
  • Gather written consent from any co-tenant or guarantor.
  • Mail the request by certified mail, return receipt requested.
  • Keep every receipt, because those dates decide your deadlines.
  • Call a New York tenant attorney if your landlord pushes back.

Most sublet problems start with a missed step, not a bad landlord. Finish this list first, and your request stands on solid ground.

Final Takeaway

Real property law section 226-b gives you a right to sublet, but it rewards the tenant who prepares. The law asks not only whether you can sublet but whether you followed the steps in order.

A request mailed by certified mail with every required item gives you a paper trail before the landlord replies.

Start with your lease, confirm your building has four or more units, and gather your subtenant’s details. If your landlord pushes back, talk to a New York tenant attorney.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does § 226-b Apply to Every Apartment in New York?

No, it covers only buildings with four or more units, and public housing and co-ops are excluded. Rent-stabilized units follow extra rules.

What if the Landlord Ignores a Sublet Request?

Silence counts as consent. If the landlord does not reply within 30 days, the sublet counts as approved, but you stay liable under the lease.

Can a Landlord Refuse an Assignment for Any Reason?

Yes, the owner can refuse an assignment without giving a reason. If the refusal is unreasonable, your only remedy is release from the lease on 30 days’ notice.

What Happens if a Tenant Sublets Without Following § 226-b?

It can count as a substantial breach of the lease, which can lead to a holdover proceeding. A clause waiving these rights is void, so you still need to follow the statute.